Big Daddy the same as a Boomstick???

[Newbie17]

I am still having some trouble deciding on which barrel I want to buy. I have changed my mind on the size though. I think I will get a 14 incher and just use my stock barrel for speedball. I am looking on the ratings page and it seems to me, overall, Smart Parts has higher ratings. Could this mean they sell a better product and have happier customers then DYE? I don't know. You tell me. If someone has owned both a Big Daddy and a Boomstick, I just want to know if they have the same accuracy. I know when it gets to higher-end barrels, most are relatively the same. I just want to know if it's true in this case. You can't beat $65 for it either. The Boomstick is $35 more. I just want to know if it's worth it. Price does not matter... I just want to know the better of the two barrels.

[Vaypourus]

I own an All American (which is similar to the Big Daddy..better IMHO). It is the second one I have owned, and I choose it over the boomstick. It was quieter, but the accuracy seemed about the same in both. I love my current All American, although I have though about buying a boomstick, simply for owning one (i prefer the looks of the Boomstick over the All American). If price is not an issue, why not buy both?

[Newbie17]

I really only want one barrel... now I am considering the Freak.